When is Fussy Too Fussy?

I started a new job a few months ago and was put on a project to update all of the documents on our SharePoint site as they needed rebranding. Sounds pretty easy, doesn’t it? Replace a few different old company words/acronyms with the new ones, replace the logo, update colors and voila, update done. Unfortunately for me, I’m also REALLY persnickety about formatting, spelling, and punctuation, so as I find documents that need fixing, I have to fix them.  It’s just not in my nature to ignore them. I’ve tried, and I absolutely, positively can’t do it.

Why is it that so many professionals in business don’t know how to create a clean, professional business document? I can’t even begin to tell you how many times I’ve seen sentences without periods at the end, confusion around common and proper nouns, commas where they don’t belong, and other assorted issues. I know, I know, you’re all rolling your eyes at me, it’s ok! I know I’m strange about stuff like this, and I can live with it.

Years ago, I had a manager who was picker than me about making documents look good, and at the time she really got on me about mistakes. I remember being upset with her at the time, but honestly, she taught me so much. (I saw her several years ago and told her how grateful I was for what she taught me, and that turned out to be one of the most gratifying conversations I have ever had!) She made me a really good proofreader…for other people’s documents, that is. For my own, not so much. I don’t know why I can’t see my own mistakes, but it’s probably because I’m too close to them. The good news is that at least I know it and ask other people to proofread for me when it’s important or run everything through spell and grammar check. I don’t know why everyone doesn’t do that. I just think it looks awful to have those kinds of mistakes in a document that is being shared outside of your team, and worse, with clients because you know that the client has someone just as odd as me, who will see those careless mistakes. (If you read a prior post from me about job hunting, you’ll remember I commented on my discovery that my spell and grammar check wasn’t working and how horrified I was about the cover letters I’d sent out.)

Another annoyance for me is not aligning numbers and bullets in a list. Use the functions built into the application to align things correctly for heaven’s sake! That’s what the indent is for, or the little tab markers in the ruler at the top of the page. I’ve seen indent used on one line, spaces on the next and nothing on a line following that, so nothing lined up correctly at all! All of this fussiness meant that my fairly simple little project grew exponentially because of my own pickiness. Yep, it’s my own fault, I know that. At least when I was done with them, they looked fantastic. Unfortunately, no one appointed me proofreading czar, so that means I’ll have to learn to bite my tongue going forward as those same people will continue to churn out documents with the same reckless abandon they always have. 

Maybe someday I’ll be in charge and can have that expectation on my team but in the meantime, I’ll have to learn to roll my eyes in silence, which is probably a good skill to have anyhow. To amuse myself in the interim I’ve been reading “Eats Shoots and Leaves: The Zero Tolerance Approach to Punctuation” by Lynne Truss. It’s a humorous look at what a difference correct punctuation makes in writing. Just the title ought to be enough to demonstrate. If one were to add a comma, it becomes “Eats, Shoots and Leaves” meaning sometime came along, ate something then took a photograph (or perhaps shot a bow and arrow or fired a gun) then left. Without the comma it is “Eats Shoots and Leaves” meaning the diet of an herbivore. Punctuation matters!

So after all my ranting above, did you find any errors I missed? Let me know, please! Also, what pet peeves in your professional life you do you have?  Feel free to share. I know I’ll feel better not being the only fussy one out there. 

Death of the Editor-2025 Kickoff

I originally was going to title this “2024 Closeout”, but then realized I didn’t have enough content for a post at the end of the year. Instead, we’ll kick off 2025 in style with more things from the internet that make you tilt your head and say “huh?”

This story about an Indiana execution and an individual with schizophrenia who killed his brother and three other men is sad enough on its own. But as you read through it, the story feels strange. First it says he was executed, then a short time later it goes on to say he COULD be executed. The story is just oddly written and the order is all wrong.

From People.com on December 30. Katie Holds to Starbucks cups…what does she hold them to? From the photo I would venture a guess that she is holding “two Starbucks cups” but hey, I could be wrong.

While not strictly filled with errors, I had to chuckle at some of the entries noted in this article on “Celebrities Known for Their Generous Tipping Habits” (I know, brainless reading one morning!) There are several listed (Ethan Hawke and Keanu Reeves, among others) that tipped 20%. Last time I checked, that wasn’t generous, that is STANDARD. Don’t get me wrong, 20% of $10,000 would certainly be a generous tip, but on the other hand, if you’re wealthy enough to afford a 10K dinner, you can afford a 2K tip. With both of these actors, the actual amount of their bill was not known, so I don’t know if the tip they provided was $50, $500 or something else. But 20% isn’t generous. Donnie Wahlberg leaving a $2020 tip on a $35 bill during the 2020 tip challenge is, however. The other funny thing about that story is the number of times the writer said that a particular actor was a generous tipper, but then listed both the bill and the amount as unknown. Well, if both are unknown, how do you KNOW they are a generous tipper?

From NBCNews.com, a clickbait story (which I did not click on to read!) about placing a bottle on your tire when traveling. Maybe it’s legit, maybe not but the content of the story isn’t the issue with this one, it’s the photo. Now call me crazy, but when you have a title that says “Place a Bottle on Your Tire When Traveling”, shouldn’t the photo show bottles and not cans? Maybe it’s just me…

And then there was this headline on January 21 in People Magazine online

 So whose 95th birthday was it? I mean, I know it’s Tippi’s and not Melanie’s, but it does read as if Melanie was 95 and her mother was something more than that.

And finally, from The Guardian on 2/6/2025, https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/feb/05/cuny-pregnant-student-protections

 When abbreviating the name of something, shouldn’t it be CUNY and not Cuny, as if Cuny was a word? It’s an ACRONYM. Sheesh.

What editorial oopsies are you spotting?